Renting the American Dream

November 10, 2025

The U.S. is in a paradox: the cost of homeownership is at record highs, while the infrastructure for family formation is fraying. Many apartments lack 3+ bedroom units almost by design, leaving growing households with no option but to stretch, double up, or move far out. Meanwhile, institutional capital is pouring into build-to-rent (BTR), seeking to deliver “house-style” rentals with private yards, street entrances, and community amenities.

Build-to-Rent (BTR) single-family homes are over $1,000–$1,200 cheaper per month to rent than to buy a comparable home, making the cost advantage both tangible and immediate for families and aspiring homeowners. With more than 110,000 new BTR units under construction, the sector is shifting from a niche alternative to a vital component of local social infrastructure. By offering family-sized rentals in good school zones, BTR can act as a bridge for family formation, capturing aspiring parents who are priced out of suburban ownership but unwilling to settle for a cramped apartment.

This story reframes the cultural script: renting a house is not settling.” It represents a generational transition in how Americans live and raise children. For this framing to succeed, BTR must avoid becoming a luxury bubble. It needs to deliver in middle markets, operate efficiently, and focus on thoughtful design. Cities should recognize that encouraging 3+ bedroom rental product (detached, townhome, duplex) near quality schools and employment centers is a pro-family zoning lever.

In short: BTR does not replace ownership. It scaffolds family life when buying is out of reach, and in doing so, rewires what aspiration means in American housing culture.

📬 Let’s Talk

Capright specializes in institutional valuation and advisory services throughout the United States. As a truly independent third-party, Capright has emerged as the leading provider mark-to-market valuations for many of the largest privately-owned commercial real estate platforms. In addition to valuation services, Capright offers NAV calculation, daily pricing, valuation process implementation, debt mark-to-market, option and JV interest valuation, compliance review, audit assistance, litigation support, and managed services. In partnership with several of the largest institutional investment managers and data platforms, Capright has pioneered industry-leading analytical tools to set higher levels of accuracy and credibility for assets requiring higher-frequency valuation compliance.

If you would like to discuss this article or need support with your SFR valuations please reach out to: